When people think of Key West cuisine, the first things that come to mind are usually conch fritters, Cuban sandwiches, and fresh-off-the-boat seafood. But here’s the insider scoop: Key West has a seriously good vegetarian food scene. Whether you’re a full-time herbivore, a flexitarian, or just craving something fresh and veggie-forward between slices of key lime pie, the island delivers.
From tropical-inspired cafés to elevated Southern comfort food with a plant-based twist, there’s no need to settle for a sad side salad when dining out in paradise. If you’re visiting for a wedding—or planning one—and want to make sure everyone at the table is happy (yes, even the meatless eaters), this is the guide for you.
Here are our picks for the top 5 restaurants in Key West with vegetarian options—plus a few bonus mentions for your foodie list.
Best Restaurants in Key West with Vegetarian Options
The Café – A Vegetarian Oasis in the Heart of Old Town
📍 509 Southard Street
Let’s start strong: The Café is a vegetarian and vegan-friendly gem that’s beloved by locals and visitors alike. It’s artsy, funky, and just a little off the beaten path, which somehow makes it even more perfect. Their entire menu is vegetarian, and most dishes can be made vegan or gluten-free with a quick request.
Popular picks include their tofu Thai curry, vegan mac ‘n’ cheese, black bean and plantain burrito, and hands-down the best vegan key lime cheesecake on the island. Everything is fresh, colorful, and plated with creativity. They also serve wine and beer and have outdoor seating tucked away from the Duval Street hustle.
Why we love it: The menu is primarily vegetarian but has some seafood options as well, so no awkward menu modifications necessary—and even your meat-eating friends will leave happy.
Best for: Low-key lunches, casual rehearsal week meals, or a welcome brunch with a health-conscious twist.
The Green Pineapple – A Fully Unique Experience
📍 310 Petronia Street
For those looking to merge wellness with delicious cuisine, The Green Pineapple Café is a fully vegetarian gem in Key West. This charming café offers a unique fusion of health-focused dining and holistic wellbeing, making it a perfect stop for the health-conscious traveler.
At The Green Pineapple Café, the menu is crafted with care, ensuring every dish is as nourishing as it is flavorful. Standout items include the vibrant Buddha Bowl, packed with fresh vegetables, quinoa, and a delectable dressing, and the Green Detox Smoothie, which is a refreshing blend of greens, fruits, and superfoods. Each item on the menu reflects a commitment to wellness and taste, promising a delightful experience for your palate and your body.
In addition to their mouth-watering menu, The Green Pineapple Café frequently hosts wellness-related events and workshops. From yoga sessions to nutrition seminars, these events provide an enriching experience that complements the café’s focus on holistic health.
Why we love it: It’s an easy place to get to with an atmosphere that is fun and casual.
Best for: A pre-wedding visit for some serious nutrition.
Date & Thyme – Organic, Clean, and Island-Chic
📍 829 Fleming Street
If you’re craving something light, fresh, and totally plant-powered, head to Date & Thyme. This organic café and wellness market is a local favorite, especially among the yoga and surf crowd. The menu is 100% vegetarian, with tons of vegan and gluten-free options.
You’ll find smoothie bowls, veggie wraps, raw pad thai, and hearty grain bowls loaded with tropical goodness. They also serve a killer turmeric latte and green juice that’s perfect for reviving your skin and energy after a day in the sun (or a night of dancing).
Why we love it: Clean ingredients, great vibes, and quick service. Also a solid spot to grab snacks for your welcome bags or Airbnb.
Best for: Morning-after wedding recovery, a healthy lunch break, or a quick takeout order between events.
Banana Café – French Flair Meets Florida Keys
📍 1215 Duval Street
Banana Café is one of those restaurants that manages to be effortlessly charming without trying too hard. Located right on Duval Street, it’s a French-inspired café that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner — with plenty of vegetarian options sprinkled throughout the menu.
Think savory crêpes with cheese and vegetables, omelets loaded with herbs and goat cheese, veggie quiches, and beautiful salads. Their espresso drinks are strong, the vibe is relaxed, and the service is friendly.
Why we love it: Great for mixed-diet groups, and the perfect spot to enjoy a long brunch with good people-watching.
Best for: Breakfast with your bridal party, low-key pre-wedding brunches, or a “just arrived” meal on the first day of your wedding weekend.
Kaya Island Eats – Flavorful and Fun Caribbean Fusion
📍 628 Petronia Street
Last but definitely not least is Kaya Island Eats, a colorful Caribbean-fusion restaurant with an adventurous (and veggie-inclusive) menu. It’s tucked away on Petronia Street in Bahama Village and offers cozy indoor and outdoor seating.
Their jackfruit tacos are famous for a reason, and their coconut curry, sweet plantains, and spicy greens keep vegetarians coming back. The vibe is unfussy and fun, with bold flavors and zero pretension.
Why we love it: Plant-based ingredients are baked into the menu—not added as an afterthought. Also: they know how to do spice.
Best for: Adventurous eaters, welcome dinners with friends, or anyone who wants a break from seafood-heavy menus.
Bonus Mentions: More Veggie-Friendly Spots to Try
While the top five above are our personal faves, here are a few more restaurants in Key West with vegetarian options worth checking out:
- Blue Heaven: Iconic Key West brunch spot with veggie omelets, benedicts, and banana pancakes. Pro tip: get there early—it gets packed.
- Clemente’s Trolley Pizzeria: Unique wood-fired pizzas with creative veggie toppings. Bonus: it’s located inside a retro trolley car.
- El Siboney: Traditional Cuban food, but vegetarians can easily enjoy black beans, rice, yuca, sweet plantains, and avocado salad.
- The Green PIneapple Cafe – Combine shopping and great, wholesome food at this unique Duval Street FIne.
Enjoy the Best Vegetarian Restaurants in Key West
Whether you’re planning a Key West wedding or just attending one, eating well—without compromising your diet or values—is totally possible. The island’s restaurant scene offers way more than just seafood platters. From tropical bowls to indulgent comfort food, these restaurants prove that flavor and freshness can go hand-in-hand with plant-based eating.
So go ahead—grab the group, make a reservation, and enjoy a meal that’s as vibrant and satisfying as your wedding weekend in Key West.
Pin This!
